The Binge Eating Monster

Don’t let this fool you; it’s a jerk.

Everyone likes food for the most part – you need it to live and it often tastes good so, yeah, you eat. Other people eat, too. I also eat, but here’s the rub; a lot of the time, when I eat, I keep eating and eating and eating and eating. Just ridiculous amounts of food that make me feel like a chubby tornado, sucking down anything edible that’s around. I know there’s a fairly sizeable amount of people like me in the world, to whom food is a crutch, or an addiction, or a comfort when issues arise. For us it’s not “I’m hungry, let’s eat, ok now I’m not hungry and will stop”.

To preface the rest of this post, I should say that I’m coming off of a binge right now. I was around 455 at my biggest, and at 250 at my smallest (as an adult((obviously))). In the last part of 2016, I went from 280 down to 250 again, and was maintaining very well, until the basement opened and out lumbered the Binge Eating Monster. I’ve since put on 40 pounds. In the last 6 months. This isn’t healthy in the BEST of conditions, so of course I am concerned and all that anxiety was causing further binge eating episodes. I stayed up late, got little sleep, and gorged myself every night when my family went to bed.

If you’ve never experienced a binge episode, imagine standing at the counter with a jar of peanut butter and a jar of jelly and eating a spoonful of each at time and being…I dunno, numb? You can’t stop, or don’t want to, or both. It’s going to McDonald’s and ordering so much because you’re afraid of running out of food while you still want to eat, so you get a combo and 20 nuggets and then something else to eat while you drive home, too. You feel guilty, disgusting, burdensome, sick, weak, and exhilarated all at the same time. Because the binge is a compulsion, satisfying that compulsion is like scratching a really bad itch, or taking a hit of a drug you miss, and while you’re in the dregs of the episode, you feel numb and detached. Afterwards, it’s nothing but regret and guilt (and often a very disagreeable stomach). You can gain a substantial amount of weight in a short period, and it’s actually dangerous because there is a positive correlation between binge eating and type 2 diabetes (and weight gain).

Monster of a problem

So it is with binge eating – it’s a process of self-indulgence brought on by compulsion and rounded out by self-loathing. There are many triggers, some more psychological and some more biological, but in the end they’re all damaging and can frustratingly exacerbate other mental health disorders AND vice-versa. You can be in your clearest mind, functioning smoothly all day, hitting step goals, making healthy lunches, and in control of your destiny, but when the Binge Eating Monster rears its ugly head, it can feel like you’re powerless. The reason I suggest the BEM (as it will be referred to from this point forward) is because, at least in my experience, it feels like domination from another force. You freeze, and you think “I should stop this” but the compulsion is so strong that it drives you to keep eating. This little imaginary creature crawls into your brain and compels you to keep eating, even though you’re an otherwise reasonable person. And that’s the key; binge eaters are often otherwise completely rational. There’s a reason that most binge eaters do it privately – it’s not just embarrassing but we also realize it’s not correct.  In fact, it’s this rationality – even when it comes to diet and healthy eating – that provides the greatest source of frustration. You can see all the angles, you can KNOW the binge eating is detrimental, but when you’re there drowning in the moment, it can be difficult to surface.

Being Rational With An Irrational Tagalong

The Binge Eating Monster doesn’t care about your goals, your upcoming class reunion, or your health in general. The compulsion simply wants to be addressed. In psychoanalytical terms  we call this an unchecked Id. The Id controls your basic primal impulses like eating and sleeping. All it’s concerned with is pleasure and food provides a lot of pleasure, so it requires your higher mental functions to keep in check, but with an overeating disorder, the Id crushes the controls you have to keep it in check.

These are some things that help me – I cannot state they’ll 100% help you, but I have read a lot of people’s personal accounts of binge eating episodes and I’ve been counseled on it. My strategies for coping and overcoming are based on my experiences and my research.

A momentary lapse of reason

1 – Before a binge, there’s often a feeling of a loss of control. This can be from stress, depression, or simply a feeling that comes out of nowhere. Any kind of loss of self-control or detachment from self can set up your BEM to take over and you absolutely don’t want that. As my wife would say, detrimental choices are caused by a detachment from your future self. That person who wants to be in great shape, or wants to heal their diabetes  – you’ll never get there if you lose sight of it. In order to prevent this loss of control, I stay focused on my weight loss and health goals. I re-read them (I write in journals a lot) every morning and at night before bed. I flip through my planner and read them midday. Staying connected to your goals is like a tether to the future, and your Binge Eating Monster can’t chew through it to take control of your actions. The more you practice self-awareness and conscious living, the stronger that tether and the weaker the Monster’s attempts become.

It’s often been expressed that willpower is like a muscle – the more you practice it, the stronger it becomes, and this is true. If you’re prone to giving into your impulses, then you will continue to do so. If however you start to tell yourself “no”, even periodically, it will become easier to do when you need to do it.

Running isn’t my favorite thing, but the BEM has little legs and can’t keep up

2 – Day-to-day, I keep up a schedule of exercise and stick to it. I lift weights 3 times a week, run 2 or 3 times a week, and do a little yoga for my lower back. Working out has a tremendous impact on your mental clarity and your ability to stick to an improvement plan. I’m not saying you need to start Crossfit, but dedicating some time everyday to exercise is a good primary habit. Secondary healthy habits, like avoiding garbage food and being mindful of your eating choices, will develop around the primary healthy habit. The various after effects of exercise, including things like rearranging your schedule and forcing yourself to make time for it, can drastically decrease the likelihood of a binge.

3 – Purge your home of your binge-trigger foods. For me, it’s peanut butter and chips (not at the same time). It’s entirely too difficult for me to stop at a few chips or a bite of peanut butter when I’m feeling weak so I avoid them until I’m mentally stronger. In my experience, binges don’t start with a meal that I’ve purposely sat down to eat. Instead, they begin during stress or sleeplessness, standing in the kitchen or pantry, and they end when I feel like a bloated, defeated creature, like a whale that’s beached itself trying to eat donuts. If those specific triggers aren’t there, I’m much less likely to binge.

4 – Give it 100%. 99%, 80%, 50% – these are incredibly difficult. No matter what your “diet” is, stick to it 100% because when you give yourself leeway, that’s when the BEM strikes. “Just one bite” turns into “just one slice” which turns into “how do I explain to anyone that I ate a whole brick-and-mortar Pizza Hut?” The Binge Eating Monster preys on your ability to justify your slip-ups. Honestly in all facets of life, the 100% policy is a very powerful way to tackle your goals.

Well, almost all facets – don’t stick to it when giving blood or something.

5 – Get help. My binge eating comes from someplace that I cannot pinpoint. This isn’t the same for everyone, though. Some people binge because of a traumatic event, and for some it’s a response to a very real biological problem. What I described above are coping strategies that work for me, but a counselor or MD can be thoroughly useful in rooting out the cause and creating a solution to your binge eating monster.


The fact of the matter is that binge eating is a mental health issue. It’s not something to be ashamed of, despite how it makes you feel. Get help, stay focused on what you want, and don’t give the BEM power. It will be something you need to work at daily, even meal-to-meal, but being mindful of it is the first step to being able to resolve it and take back control of your life.




  • Christina Reply

    I know it may seem insurmountable at times, but you really seem to have a handle on the BEM. You can kick his ass, you can do it!!!

    • Monechetti Reply

      Thanks! I have it, for good this time.

      Only took me 33 year haha.

  • jodie filogomo Reply

    I think we all struggle at times with this. I have learned not to hang out in the kitchen for one thing!

    • Monechetti Reply

      No doubt – I do most of the cooking, so a lot of times when the food is done, I’m already full haha.

  • Jennifer Reply

    Just by writing this down, acknowledging it and putting a face to your BEM will help you to move forward.

    • Monechetti Reply

      It certainly has so far. 🙂

  • Debbie Reply

    Your honesty and openness must be the start of getting this under control.

    • Monechetti Reply

      I have found that’s the case – addressing a problem, especially when not in the throes of it, is essential to treating it. Thanks for reading!

  • #3 is so important to me! If it’s not in my house then I can’t eat it and we live 20 minutes from the nearest decent store. I have a magnet on my fridge that says, “If you keep good food in your fridge, you’ll eat good food” 🙂

    • Monechetti Reply

      That’s a brilliant saying honestly. Our fridge right now is packed with produce and I’ve made it a priority to ensure I’ve got at least 1 vegetable-heavy side every night this week. My kids are even eating the stuff, haha.

    • Monechetti Reply

      It haunts us all.

  • Gary A. Mathews Reply

    In a former life the BEM monster would show up at my house in the form of the extra large Cheez-Its. He would take over, and convince me to go to Costco or Sam’s Club and by an even larger box. The struggle is real, but it sounds like you have the BEM kryptonite!

    • Monechetti Reply

      I’m trying, but Cheez-Its, oh what is the deal with them? When I would binge, I’d make sure I had a second box around because I would fully eat a whole box and my kids would be without cheese squares. THEY’RE SO GOOD.

  • Silly Mummy Reply

    Good tips. I have a history of anorexia. Mostly I was restrictive, but like most anorexics over the long term, would have occasional periods of ‘binge-purge’. In reality, what an anorexic would class as a ‘binge’ would be pretty different to what others would class as a binge, but the emotions surrounding it of loss of control and self loathing were the same, the eating without even actually enjoying it. Issues of any kind surrounding food can be very difficult to kick and get under control, and I think most – if not all – of us who have had any kind of disordered eating always have those tendencies there and have to monitor the situation all the time.

  • Laurie Stone Reply

    Sometimes before a binge I try and remember how I’ll feel after, which is horrible, especially if it involves tons of sugar. Sometimes that helps. Sometimes I still need to binge. As long as they’re not too often, I think they’re okay. But if its more than once a week (at least for me) I know I’m running off the rails. Your self-awareness is a great asset.

  • Robin Reply

    You can do this, Tony! I find that when I feel the urge to go “eat something,” I try to press the imaginary “pause” button on eating to see if I know why I’m about to eat. If it’s anything other than actual hunger — accompanied by audible rumbling of my stomach — I try to distract myself with something else, even if it’s stepping outside for a breath of fresh air. It’s so hard, but it has to be done. Every day you don’t binge is a day closer to kicking the BEM’s you-know-what! Stay strong!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *